Review:
Trouble with the Curve is a
great baseball movie – and almost a complete rebuttal to 2011’s
Moneyball
– that has not forgotten the most important ingredient to any film is good
characters. It is about Gus, a scout for the Atlanta Braves, who is on his last
legs professionally. The game is changing and his eyes are failing. He is sent
out on what could be his final assignment to scout what many believe to be a
sure thing. His daughter Mickey, who grew up on the road with him but now has a
difficult relationship, decides to tag along to help her father out so he can
keep his job and passion for a few more years.
Director
Robert Lorenz knows the secret
to what makes a good Hollywood-style film: relatable characters with a clear
story arc. He also knows his target audience. Gus is lost in today’s world. He
does not understand technology and he hates the way Sabermetrics are taking
over the process by which talent is analyzed in baseball. It makes him, and all
scouts (an important aspect that shapes of the game), obsolete. He is out to
prove that a computer cannot really fully understand a player. Lorenz has
multiple examples that make Gus’s point. He may be an ornery old man who is out
of touch in a lot of ways, but he still is completely in tune with the game of
baseball. This appeals in many ways to the audience. The audience (especially
the targeted older movie-goers that make up
Clint Eastwood’s typical
demographic) relates to Gus because they feel the same way about the world that
is becoming more and more technology savvy and dependent, leaving out
generations. Trouble with the Curve is about a man fed up with this widening
generational gap and that speaks to the target audience. Thus, the audience is
very much invested in Gus. And, for other audience demographics, Lorenz has
created a fleshed out character that can be related to through humor (as there
is a fair amount of funny material).
Gus’s daughter Mickey is also a
strong character that the audience can latch on to. She is a successful lawyer
who loves her father but is frustrated by their lack of communication – a
common theme in many families. The character also provides a nice juxtaposition
to Eastwood’s strong-but-silent stoic character (that he is famous for), because
she shows the issues that have been created between her and her father due to
his lack of communication with her. The narrative (which does not really need
her, though it would be a slightly different story without her) is all the more
compelling because the audience sees the deconstruction of Eastwood’s own
archetype.
As this is a Hollywood-style
narrative, Lorenz does not shy away from having a fairly predictable and safe
structure, complete with the happy ending. But, with this kind of film, the happy
ending is not just expected it is demanded. Imagine the story of Gus being left
by his daughter and eclipsed by technology (i.e. being wrong about the players
while the computers are right). The story would be rather dark and would end
with Gus probably killing himself or letting himself go in humiliating total
defeat. It would be heartbreaking. Trouble with the Curve, however, is not this
type of him and that is not the type of film that Eastwood’s target audience
wants to see. However, that being said, the film’s narrative structure does
leave it feeling a little lazy and wrapped up in a nice Hollywood bow. For
some, this will hurt the film, as the structure and character archetypes will
feel overly played out and tired (and too safe). But, taking the film at face
value, the narrative works well for the story that Eastwood and Lorentz want to
tell.
I have said before that baseball
translates itself to cinema better than any other sport, as it seems to have
the most human aspect to it. It is a game that is specifically about individual
achievement, while still being a team sport. A pitcher and hitter are alone as
they face one and other. And thus, it lends itself perfectly to being inhabited
by great characters as a backdrop. Baseball seems to accentuate the human
emotions and drama of the characters, as it is a very nostalgic pastime for the
audience. So, to make a great baseball movie, a filmmaker merely needs
well-drawn characters in a baseball setting (with seemingly a hint of wonder
and majesty), and have a love of the game – which is evident in all involved in
this film. It is also a great baseball movie because it gets back to the quirky and magical intricacies that make baseball the special wondrous game that it is, and away from the dehumanizing numbers that dominate today. As someone that seems to be drawn to nostalgic things from my childhood, I like this, as I remember the fun I had in little league. The film speaks to both the fan and child just playing the game in all of us.
Trouble with the Curve is going
to work best for those that like and understand baseball (though it is not a
mandatory requirement) and enjoy good characters and well done character drama.
Technical,
aesthetic & acting achievements: Robert Lorenz makes his feature
debut with Trouble with the Curve. He served as Clint Eastwood’s producing
partner on Eastwood’s last ten films (as well as second-unit director on a few
others) prior to this. Lorenz decided to take a very straightforward approach
to the material, shooting it in a very typical Hollywood style (standard
coverage), which worked for the material.
Marco Beltrami’s score is also
fairly standard – emphasizing the dramatic beats.
Tom Stern’s cinematography and
James J. Murakami’s production
design work with the Hollywood style aesthetic of Lorenz’s narrative as well.
The photography is glossy, making even the small town ballparks look majestic
and magical (being a common theme in baseball movies), while the production
design reinforces the characters and narrative. It is very good work (as to be
expected from these two).
For a character drama like this
to work, the performances must be good. In Trouble with the Curve, the
performances are the strongest aspect of the film.
John Goodman and
Matthew Lillard are good in
smaller roles.
Justin Timberlake
brings a lot of charisma and likability to the film, as well as a change of
pace from the more stubborn and combative leads.
Amy Adams is maybe the best part
of the film. She plays Mickey to be very strong and independent, but still
insecure when it comes to her father. I also really liked the fact that she is
completely in love with baseball, and cannot fight it, even in her grownup life.
Clint Eastwood plays the same old gruff, cantankerous and grumpy man that he
seems to always being playing these days (see
Gran Torino or
Million Dollar Baby for
reference). And as usual, it works to great effect. He is compelling and has
fun with it.
Summary
& score: Trouble with the Curve is really just the same old
Hollywood style drama about two characters learning to connect that we have
seen hundreds of times and thus is very predictable, but with great characters
and a baseball setting the film is still very engaging. 7/10