Showing posts with label J. Edgar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label J. Edgar. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

J. Edgar (2011) – Review

Review: J. Edgar is a mix of things that work and things that do not work, but ultimately ends up being a good biography, just weighed down by odd and clumsy choices. The film is about the career of J. Edgar Hoover – his rise through the Justice Department becoming the founder of the Federal Bureau of Investigation to the power hungry seemingly out-of-touch petty old man still clinging to whatever power he has left. Director Clint Eastwood structures the film to be told through the writing of Hoover’s biography, cutting frequently between the past (mostly the 1920s and 1930s) and the present (1960s). The past reveals a man driven to create a better crime-stopping force, while dealing with issues of an over aggrandized ego and social awkwardness. The present however, just shows the man as sort of a wretch nefariously doing whatever to hang on to power and promote himself above all else, crippled by having to hide part of himself from the world. As a straight-forward biography, the film is at its best, and Eastwood’s style seems to be at its most comfortable – focusing on the look of the times, deeds and facts (though the film presents them as being a bit on the fuzzy side, as Hoover is an unreliable narrator/protagonist) is when the film is the most engaging and interesting. However, it is when Eastwood delves into Hoover’s character specifically the relationships that he has with his mother, life-long secretary Helen Gandy and friend/FBI colleague Clyde Tolson that the film seems to drag and not work. Sticking out the most are two factors: first, Eastwood’s piano score (especially in the scenes with his mother and later Clyde) feels completely wrong for the tone and takes the viewer out of the film. Second, the casting (and/or performances) is very uneven. Many scenes simply do not work primarily due to actors mismatched to roles, which is most prevalent in Hoover’s relationship with Tolson. Plus, Eastwood structuring the film to be about Hoover’s career as told by him disconnects the audience when it suddenly veers into ‘character scenes’ (again, especially those with his mother) as it halts the momentum. The film very well may have benefitted from a different structure – given the need to explain why Hoover was the way he was, while also reviewing his career highlights. The three characters closest to Hoover (his mother, secretary and best friend Clyde) are all quite strange, seemingly giving up their lives to solely support his, which makes them problematic as film characters as they really have no depth (maybe with the exception of Clyde who is actually given some dramatic beats) when they need to so that their relationships actually have meaning for the viewer. Rather than being fully fleshed out characters, they simply exist to help shape Hoover – who is very well fleshed out and with a great performance given by Leonardo DiCaprio is really the reason the film works at all or is interesting at all. DiCaprio carries every scene he is in. And while this is a film about Hoover, driving deeper into the supporting characters would have given the audience a better understanding of who these people were and why they acted the way they did towards Hoover, shaping him. As is, they just seem very odd, and tragic given the times and social perception of same-sex relationships (and maybe that is the point Eastwood wanted to make – not only was Hoover self-destructive to a certain extent, but he also ruined those closest to him as well). Despite J. Edgar’s many flaws, Eastwood does still manage to make a good biography, especially for those interested in the man, his deeds and the times.


Technical, aesthetic & acting achievements: Clint Eastwood has long established himself as one of the best auteur directors working today (even though I would argue that his last few efforts were not that strong). With J. Edgar, it is clear that he still has the ability to make a film with great aesthetics and performances (there are just structural and character issues). Eastwood has worked with the same team on his last five films to very good results (regardless of whether the film worked or not). Tom Stern’s cinematography is again excellent, and the very desaturated look matched both the tone of the film and character of Hoover. James J. Murakami’s production design is also very good, and challenging as he needed to work in multiple decades – and yet there is a style continuity that still exists throughout seamlessly. Eastwood provides his own score, as he often does (since 2003). It is not only the weakest of the artistic elements of the film, but also damages the narrative and tone overall as it does not work or fit at all, which is unfortunate. It completely disengages the audience and seems to bring the narrative momentum to a sudden and jarring (not in a good way) halt. Performance wise, J. Edgar is all over the place. Judi Dench is fine in her performance as Hoover’s mother, but her character is given no depth making all her scenes boring, as they bring the narrative to a stop, essentially (save for the ‘daffy’ scene). Naomi Watts is good as Hoover’s secretary, but is really given very little drama or acting to do. Armie Hammer seems completely miscast as Hoover’s best friend and colleague Clyde Tolson (just as Jeffrey Donovan seems awfully miscast as Robert Kennedy), or his performance is just off (and maybe both). He is given some dramatic scenes, but they seem to come too late and too few. DiCaprio, however, is very good as Hoover, which is a challenging role, playing a complex and issue-ridden man across multiple decades, who hides himself from the world his whole life in public and private – playing the character of the perfect moral man, if you will, while secretly feeling differently. Again, he completely carries the film and is the reason it works at all.

Summary & score: As a period biopic, J. Edgar is very good. But as a character drama, it does not work nearly well enough. However, the former carries the latter enough to make it a good film. 7/10

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Leonardo DiCaprio – Movies Spotlight – November 2011

Leonardo DiCaprio, 37, is still probably best known for his role opposite Kate Winslet in James Cameron’s Titanic. However, in recent years he has become one of the best leading men in Hollywood. This month he stars in the Clint Eastwood directed biopic J. Edgar about J. Edgar Hoover, the first director of the FBI.

Early Career:

DiCaprio began his career making appearances in commercials and educational films before getting his first break picking up a role in the soup Santa Barbara and a series regular role in Parenthood (the short-lived series based on the Ron Howard movie) in 1990. He continued to get TV work with roles on Roseanne and Growing Pains, and he got his first film role in 1991 on the sci-fi comedy Critters 3 and then another in Poison Ivy. His work on Parenthood garnered him a nomination for Best Young Actor from the Young Artist Awards. However, it was not until Robert De Niro chose him out of four hundred young actors to co-star with him that he had his real breakthrough. The film was 1993’s This Boy’s Life.

Breakthrough as a Child-Actor:

After This Boy’s Life, DiCaprio followed it up with another fantastic performance in What’s Eating Gilbert Grape, co-starring and even upstaging Johnny Depp as Depp’s mentally handicapped brother. Director Lasse Hallstrom was reluctant to cast him at first, as he felt DiCaprio was too good-looking for the role, but found that he was the best among the auditions by far. He earned his first Oscar nomination for the performance. Next, he worked with Sam Raimi on the campy western The Quick and the Dead playing the cocky son of the town’s big man. DiCaprio’s performance is fun, the film does feature a few great actors (like Gene Hackman and Russell Crowe) and is entertaining in spots, but it does not hold up too well as a whole. He also made his next critical hit in 1995 with The Basketball Diaries, a biopic about Jim Carroll.


Titanic – Becoming the Biggest Star in the World:

DiCaprio had established himself as a good young actor, one that critics knew and praised, but he was not yet a star or box office draw. That changed in 1996 when he was cast opposite Claire Danes (who was the bigger of the two, star wise, at the time thanks to My So-Called Life) in Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo + Juliet. Luhrmann updated the style and look of Shakespeare’s play to feel more modern and hip and cast Danes and DiCaprio in an effort to appeal to younger film goers, and it worked. Even today, the film is one of the most iconic romances of its generation. Next, he took a role in Marvin’s Room playing opposite Robert De Niro again, as well as Meryl Streep and Diane Keaton, truly testing his skills as an actor.  The film is okay, but DiCaprio came out of it being called an equal to the wonderful actors sharing the screen. Now having both critical praise and commercial appeal, he was ready to become a huge star. The film that did it for him was his next – Titanic. Before Avatar topped it, Titanic was the highest grossing film of all-time, and it won eleven Oscars including Best Picture. It made DiCaprio one of the biggest stars in Hollywood and also one of the main heartthrobs from teenage girls. However, the film also had some backlash for him, as it was too big and a little too sappy. Critics and some audience members seemed to dislike him purely due to his association with the film and line ‘I’m the king of the world’, which was on repeat in pop-culture after the film (and to some extent still is). He may never be quite as popular as he was around the time of that movie. Now, as a big star, studios started to place him in bigger films. First up was United Artists’ The Man in the Iron Mask, directed and written by Randal Wallace, coming off his big hit Braveheart (which he wrote). The movie was a failure critically but made money commercially. He then made Celebrity with Woody Allen, which is one of Allen’s lesser films, appearing in a self-mocking cameo. And then Fox put him in The Beach, the second of their two film experiment with director Danny Boyle that yielded two disappointments for them critically (though I am a fan of both The Beach and A Life Less Ordinary). However, the film was a success at the box office thanks to DiCaprio’s fame (and the same goes for The Man in the Iron Mask). Both films garnered him Razzie nominations (not because he is bad in them, but due to the Titanic backlash).


Collaborations with Martin Scorsese:

DiCaprio has had one of his most fruitful actor-director relationships with Martin Scorsese. They have made four films together, beginning with Gangs of New York in 2002. Scorsese initially had trouble getting a studio interested in the film, but when DiCaprio became interested in starring, coming off three box office hits in a row, Miramax jumped in to finance the project. However, the filming was plagued with creative disputes between Scorsese and the producers as well as multiple budget overflows. It is the most expense film Scorsese has made. Despite the issues, the film received critical acclaim (for the most part, though I would argue it is one of his lesser films) and ten Oscar nods including Best Picture. While DiCaprio is good in it, giving his first grown-up performance (so to speak), he is overshadowed by Daniel Day-Lewis’s magnificent performance. Their next picture together came in 2004 with The Aviator, a biopic about Howard Hughes. DiCaprio originally developed the project with Michael Mann, but he decided to leave the director’s chair and only produce as he had just made two biopics (Ali and The Insider) and did not want to take on a third just then. DiCaprio decided to pitch the script to Scorsese after having a good working relationship with him on Gangs of New York. He spent over a year preparing for the role, which was his most difficult to date (and probably still is). The film was a financial and critical success and DiCaprio received his second Oscar nomination. In 2006 the two worked together again on The Departed, a remake of the Hong Kong film Infernal Affairs. The film was highly anticipated and became the biggest hit critically and commercially among their films together. It won Best Picture and Scorsese a Best Director Oscar at the 2007 Academy Awards. They again reunited in 2009 to make Sutter Island (which was delayed until 2010). The film is much different than most of the work either had done previously, being a psychological thriller, but it yielded both DiCaprio and Scorsese their biggest box office opening weekend of their careers to date. The pair is currently working on a few upcoming rumored projects together.


Working with the Best Directors in Hollywood:

In addition to Martin Scorsese, DiCaprio has worked with many of the best directors in Hollywood since 2002 starting with Steven Spielberg on Catch Me If You Can. DiCaprio’s performance as Frank Abagnale Jr., a very skilled forger and con-man, seemed to make him cool again with many viewers put off by Titanic. And likewise, the film was a great international success (and one of Spielberg’s better films of the decade, second to Munich). He made Blood Diamond with Edward Zwick about the Sierra Leone Civil War in 2006. He played a South African and donned an Afrikaner’s accent. He received his third Oscar nomination for the film. In 2008 he made two films, first he worked with Ridley Scott on Body of Lies, a CIA spy Middle East thriller. DiCaprio liked the film because he viewed it as a throwback to the political films of the 1970s (things like The Parallax View and Three Days of the Condor). Then he reunited with Kate Winslet in Sam Mendes’s (her husband at the time) Revolutionary Road about a failing marriage in the 1950s. Both DiCaprio and Winslet had been reluctant to work on romances in the wake of Titanic, but had remained good friends. Thus, when Winslet came with the project to DiCaprio he agreed and production started quickly. Both are fantastic in the film (and it is one of the most underrated films of the year and possibly decade). In 2010 he starred in Christopher Nolan’s action thriller Inception, yet another critical and commercial success. These films have not only made DiCaprio one of the top leading men from a talent perspective, but also one of the biggest stars in Hollywood currently.

Future Projects:

DiCaprio has two films upcoming in 2012, both scheduled for a release on Christmas Day. First he is reuniting with his Romeo + Juliet director Baz Luhrmann for an adaptation of The Great Gatsby. It co-stars Carey Mulligan as Daisy and Tobey Maguire (who he worked with on This Boy’s Life) as Nick. Then, he takes on his first role as a villain in Quentin Tarantino’s southern western Django Unchained. It is about a slave turned bounty hunter who sets out to rescue his wife from a vicious plantation owner (played by DiCaprio). It stars Jamie Foxx and co-stars Samuel L. Jackson, Christoph Waltz, and Kerry Washington (among others). DiCaprio is also rumored to be attached to Todd Fields’s new film Creed of Violence about two men in 1910 who try to stop an organized arms smuggling ring.


Leonardo DiCaprio’s Career Highlights:

1)      What’s Eating Gilbert Grape (1993) – supporting (DVD, Streaming)
2)      The Basketball Diaries (1995) – leading (Blu-ray, DVD)
3)      Romeo + Juliet (1996) – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
4)      Titanic (1997) – leading (DVD)
5)      Gangs of New York (2002) – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
6)      Catch Me If You Can (2002)* – leading (DVD)
7)      The Aviator (2004) – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
8)      The Departed (2006)* – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
9)      Blood Diamond (2006) – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
10)   Body of Lies (2008)* – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
11)   Revolutionary Road (2008)* – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
12)   Shutter Island (2010) – leading (Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming)
13)   Inception (2010)* – leading (Blu-ray, DVD)
*Editor’s picks

Thursday, October 27, 2011

At the Movies – November 2011 – Part 3: This Month’s Best Films

Must-See of the Month:

The Muppets (James Bobin) – Comedy – Nov 23
Summary: Like the classic Muppet movies, this is about the Muppets coming together to save their theatre (from a greedy oil tycoon, specifically for this film). Filmmakers: Director James Bobin of The Flight of the Cochords and The Ali G Show makes his feature debut. Jason Segel (who is also starring and producing) and Nicholas Stroller wrote the script (they made Forgetting Sarah Marshall together), Bret McKenzie is writing a few new songs, Christophe Beck (Crazy, Stupid, Love.) is scoring, Don Burgess (Source Code) is shooting, and Steve Saklad (Up in the Air) is doing the production design. Cast: In addition to the Muppets and Segel, Amy Adams stars and Rashida Jones and Chris Cooper feature in supporting roles. The film also boasts an impressive list of celebrity cameos (here is a full list), highlighted by: Neil Patrick Harris, Emily Blunt, Ricky Gervais, Donald Glover, and Billy Crystal. Expectations: While I am a fan of the Muppets, it is Jason Segel, James Bobin and Bret McKenzie’s involvement in the production of the film that has me excited to see it (just think of Segel’s Dracula Musical in Forgetting Sarah Marshall). The cast and celebrity cameos are also awesome. The myriad of joke and real trailers have been great as well. More so than many of the Holiday family-targeted films coming out in November and December, this has the most potential to be amazing for both children and adults. This is definitely the must-see of the month. Trailer: Here. Review.

Worth Checking Out:

J. Edgar (Clint Eastwood) – Biography – Nov 9
Summary: The film is about J. Edgar Hoover, the first director of the FBI – his life, career and secrets. Filmmakers: This project seems like a very good fit for director, producer and composer Clint Eastwood (he has made some good period stuff in the past, like his recent film Changeling). The film is written by Oscar winner (for Milk) Dustin Lance Black, and Eastwood is working with his frequent collaborators cinematographer Tom Stern and production designer James Murakami. Cast: The strong cast starts with the lead Leonardo DiCaprio, but it also has a good supporting group with Armie Hammer, Naomi Watts, Dermot Mulroney, Josh Lucas, Ed Westwick, Lea Thompson, Judi Dench, Jeffrey Donovan, and Stephen Root. Expectations: Clint Eastwood and Leonard DiCaprio being a part of J. Edar automatically makes it an Oscar contender. Eastwood is a fantastic director, but he is not immune to films that do not entirely work (his last two, Invictus and Hereafter, were not great). But, DiCaprio has a very strong record with his recent projects (his last three were Revolutionary Road, Shutter Island and Inception – all receiving a review of 8 or better from me). More than likely, this will be good. Trailer: Here. Review.

The Descendants (Alexander Payne) – Dramedy – Nov 18 [limited]
Summary: The film is about Matt King. After the death of his wife in a boating accident, he tries to reconnect with his two daughters. Filmmakers: Writer-director Alexander Payne is one of the best at making dramedies because his characters are well drawn and typically sad (specifically his protagonists), and yet his dialog and situations he places them in are often very funny (his masterwork is probably Sideways). He is working with frequent collaborators cinematographer Phedon Papamichael (who did maybe the best work of his career to date on The Ides of March) and production designer Jane Ann Stewart. Cast: George Clooney stars with Judy Greer, Matthew Lillard, Shailene Woodley, Beau Bridges, Robert Forster, and Rob Huebel in support. Expectations: This is another Oscar contender (probably picture, screenplay and actor), due to its acclaim from critics based on its festival screenings. I generally really like Payne’s work, and this looks to be no different – complex characters, moving drama and very funny. Trailer: Here. Review.

A Dangerous Method (David Cronenberg) – Drama – Nov 23
Summary: The film is about the relationship between Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung and a patient Sabina Spielrein, and the birth of psychoanalysis. Filmmakers: Director David Cronenberg is known for his graphic style (both in the way he shoots violence and the mental conditions of his characters, who are often pushed to their limits). He is a beloved indie director with films like Eastern Promises, A History of Violence and The Fly. He is working with frequent collaborators composer Howard Shore, cinematographer Peter Suschitzky and production designer James McAteer (who has worked many times with Cronenberg as an art director, however this is his first major feature as production designer). Cast: The film stars Viggo Mortensen, Michael Fassbender and Keira Knightley. Vincent Cassel and Sarah Gadon have supporting roles, making for an overall excellent group. Expectations: A Dangerous Method has played very well for critics during its festival run with some believing it is an Oscar contender in a few of the major categories come 2012 (picture, directing and acting). I am looking forward to it simply because it is a modern auteur director and a fantastic cast (it is one of my top five most anticipated films yet to come out in 2011 – the others being Tinker Tailor Solider Spy, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol, and The Muppets). Trailer: Here. Review.