Showing posts with label Red Riding Trilogy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Red Riding Trilogy. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Amazing British Television – TV Spotlight – February 2011

TV Series: Luther (BBC One)
Creator(s): Neil Cross
Plot Summary: John Luther is a brilliant yet unhinged, destructive Detective Chief Inspector (DCI) who specializes in catching exotic and strange murderers by getting inside their minds. The series opens with Luther returning from suspension (and nervous breakdown) rejoining his special murder unit, but all is not right when he finds that his wife has moved on and that he may not be completely mentally stable.
Why You Need to See It: The series is one of the best mystery/detective shows of all-time. The cast is absolutely brilliant, highlighted by staggeringly great performances by Idris Elba and Steven Mackintosh and a star making turn from Ruth Wilson, who commands the screen and the viewer’s attention whenever she is in a scene. The dynamic that develops between Alice (Wilson) and Luther (Elba) is fantastic (I do not want to spoil anything, just watch it). The writing is also excellent. The series builds over its six episodes, tightening the tension and expectation until the viewer can barely breathe. It is quite exceptional. If you like detective series, you need to see this one. BBC One has commissioned a second series for 2011 consisting of two two-hour episodes (so like four regular episodes). Check out the trailer.
Available On: DVD and to Rent

TV Series: Sherlock (BBC One)
Creator(s): Mark Gatiss and Steven Moffat
Plot Summary: The series is a modern-day update of the Sherlock Holmes stories, featuring many of the notable characters. The show begins with Sherlock Holmes, an unofficial consultant to the police, assisting in the investigation of a series of suicides by poisonous pill. Meanwhile, Holmes meets John Watson and the two become friends – Watson dragged into helping Holmes solve the case and try to find out who is really behind it all.
Why You Need to See It: The modern take on the stories breathes new life into the characters. It is really funny, but also action packed making for a great detective/mystery series. Each of the three ninety minute episodes is excellent, creating a world that while set in modern London is completely loyal to the source material in tone and charisma. Cumberbatch and Freemen have tons of chemistry and make for an amazingly good Holmes and Watson team (and friendship). The writing is also very good with wonderful stories and lots of wit (it really blows the recent film version out of the water – well it is different, and better).  This is a must see for fans of the books and characters, or if you just like a great detective TV show. BBC One has commissioned a second series (again with three ninety minute episodes) to air in late 2011. Check out the trailer.
Available On: Blu-ray, DVD and to Rent

TV Series: Red Riding Trilogy (Channel 4)
Creator(s): Tony Grisoni
Plot Summary: The series based on David Peace’s novels, is about police and government corruption in Northern England in the 70s/early 80s with the Yorkshire Ripper case serving as the backdrop (though fictionalized from the real events). The series is split into three films: 1974, 1980 and 1983.
Why You Need to See It: Aesthetically speaking, this is one of the most brilliant pieces of television ever done. Each part had its own director and crew, and thus a slightly different look and feel. But, the directors were able to maintain an overall tonal continuity to the series. Personally, I feel that 1974 is the best part, as it features an amazing performance from 2010’s breakout star Andrew Garfield, excellent directing from Julian Jarrold and exceptional cinematography from Rob Hardy (among the best I saw in 2010). Parts two and three are also very good, but part one is special. The series also has a number of great supporting performances (especially the work of Sean Harris, who is brilliant and scary, and Rebecca Hall) that supplement and push the great work from the three leads (a different one in each part). The material is very dark and intense, more so than most TV productions, but this is well worth seeing for fans of mysteries, because this is really not only a good story but also a piece of art and fine filmmaking. Check out the trailer.
Available On: Blu-ray, DVD and to Rent (1974, 1980 & 1983)

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Red Riding: In the Year of Our Lord 1983 (2010) – Review

Red Riding: In the Year of Our Lord 1983 (from now on being referred to as Red Riding: 1983) is the third part of the Red Riding Trilogy (see part 1 and part 2). The film is a detective-style mystery, again with motifs of corruption and literal corruption (and it is honestly going to be hard to delve too deep into the discussion of the use of corruption in the film without spoilers, but I will try my best). The police are corrupt, the township’s elite are corrupt – this is clearly shown (wonderfully summed up in the best line in the film “To the North – where we do what we bloody want!”), but how corruption of the soul affects the human element of the characters is different. In the first two films, the main characters were to an extent innocent at the beginning only to be corrupted and destroyed. Here, the main characters are within the system and begin to feel remorseful for what they have done or the way things are. And what is interesting about the narrative is that even though Maurice Jobson is very much a contributing factor to corruption apparent in Yorkshire the viewer is quick to align with him when guilt has his conscience looking for redemption. Is it because Jobson, while certainly a part of it, is not as bad as the really bad men, or are we, as humans, yearning to look for the good? John Piggott on the other hand has been diminished by the death of his father, yet given a chance to redeem himself and do something positive with his life – he is initially hesitant. It is not until something unmistakable happens that he is truly committed. These two characters fulfill the role of detective for the audience – Piggott the more traditional detective and similar to the first two main characters in the series, while Jobson serves more of an informational role in the narrative. His flashbacks and discoveries aid the viewer in uncovering the truth, but he does not seem to directly help Piggott. The flashbacks are really the most interesting parts of the film, and are all fantastically shot and staged. Since the viewer has gone through two films, knows the past, knows the characters, deeper insight into the characters and their motivations is a welcome device. However, the flashbacks are almost seamlessly cut with the present making it at times difficult to initially tell when and where characters are, but this is really only a minor issue. The character of BJ has an interesting transition throughout the series. Finally, in Red Riding: 1983 he, like the other main characters, is able to stand up and say enough and act to find his salvation and escape. The Wolf’s identity also plays heavily into the idea of the corruption of man juxtaposed to societal ideals for man, who and what should be the best of men. The most evil men in the series are those most trusted in society to do right and be right. Thus, the message of the series seems that even in the darkest corners of human corruption (I have used this word so many times across these three reviews), there is still salvation and escape possible for the good men – light in the dark if you will, which is echoed by the final shot (the whole series has been gloomy, but the final shot is sunny and bright). The series overall demands astute attention from its viewers or they will surely be lost and not catch everything that they need to fully understand the story. And yet, here is where the final part feels like a letdown. It is a good film, well made and acted, but it does not feel complete. For a series that did demand much from its audience, it seems to end very abruptly and with many lingering questions. The main narrative question is answered, rest assured, but the viewer is left to make assumptions on many seemingly key subplots and continuations of the main thread (aka, we find out who the Wolf is – but are left without any other definitive concrete actions to sum up the story). Despite this weakness (caused more by the narrative across the series rather than the film itself), Red Riding: 1983 is another good mystery film in the very good series.


Technical achievements: director Anand Tucker has apparent talent, which is on display in this film, but often is unable to make satisfyingly complete narratives. His use of the camera to alert viewers to details, scene blocking and ability to get good performances are his strengths, but he succeeds more at directing scenes than a full film that flows (though, this is his best film to date). David Higgs’s cinematography is very good, which it needed to be, as both the first two parts are remarkably shot (he used the Red One digital camera). The use of light in the flashbacks is aesthetically interesting and accomplished a “in the past” feel for those scenes. It is a subtle but nice touch. Alison Dominitz’s production design and Barrington Pheloung’s score are also on par with the previous films and fit the tone and atmosphere of the series. David Morrissey finally got to show his acting chops. He is able to be very emotive with his eyes which give his performance a nice layered journey. Mark Addy is also quite good in the film. He does a great job playing a damaged character. Daniel Mays, Peter Mullan and Robert Sheehan are the standouts among a good supporting cast. The series in general has been filled with very good performances and great work from the directors and crew – this film is no different.

Red Riding: 1983 is at its best as a mystery and character study of tarnished men, but does not seem to answer all the questions which would more effectively wrap up the series. 7/10

The Red Riding Trilogy is available on Blu-ray and DVD on Amazon.com or stream Red Riding: 1983 on Netflix.com

Thursday, September 23, 2010

Red Riding: In the Year of Our Lord 1980 (2010) – Review

Red Riding: In the Year of Our Lord 1980 (from now on being referred to as Red Riding: 1980) is the second part of the Red Riding Trilogy (see part 1’s review). Red Riding: 1980 continues the corruption motif from part one, but overall is a drastically different film, stylistically, tonally and structurally, which is beneficial to it as it has its own identity. It is a much more a straightforward detective style mystery – the plot to uncover the mystery drives the story, and not so much the emotional journey of the characters. Corruption in the first is an abstract force that consumes and ultimately destroys Edward. Here, corruption is a much more literal concept. It is clear that the Yorkshire police department is corrupt (as we have seen the first part) and that something is not right with the case that Peter Hunt is being brought in to solve, not to mention that he has bad history with the police department and is convinced that they were hiding something. Unlike Edward, Peter is not an innocent in the world. He tries so hard to expose the truth, but he is having an affair and is distant from his wife emotionally – truths that he cannot come to terms with internally. If the first was about the corruption of the innocent, then this film is about corruption as a fact of life. Seemingly ever character his damaged in the film. There is no salvation apparent here (though, I get the sense that the third will be about salvation). As much as Peter wants to expose the truth, there seems to be a naivety to him, which is ultimately his downfall. Clearly, everything is grey in the world of the film, but Peter tries to see it as black and white. Director James Marsh does an excellent job visually exploring the slow realization that Peter has that he in fact is not the shining white knight in to save the day. The narrative is structured as a detective mystery – the detective (and team) find clues, uncover the mystery and solve the case by the end. And as such, the plot compels the story forward, not the characters. While the characters do have emotional journeys, they are complimentary and serve the plot (for the most part), and thus are not the focus. The downside of this is that none of the characters are fully fleshed out. Thus, the audience does not have a full emotional connection to them and are therefore not themselves emotionally engaged in the journey and outcome for the characters. Rather, they are engaged by the story – to see how it turns out. There is nothing wrong with this, but emotional connection has a deeper lasting effect on the viewer, and truly caring about the outcome of the characters leads to a more fulfilling experience than just wanting to see what happens next. And this is really the only issue, but an important one holding it back from being a great film. The mystery itself is engaging and interesting, but the lack of true connection with the main character, especially, leaves the film feeling satisfying from a story standpoint just not completely fulfilling. Red Riding: 1980 has everything a good mystery film should, but is just missing a deeper layer of emotional connection.


Technical achievements: James Marsh working with director of photography Igor Martinovic (again) made a very interestingly shot film. On the outside it appears fairly straightforward, but scenes like Peter Hunt’s visit to the mining town (It is such a striking scene and one of the most interesting on the year), Marsh’s use of visual narrative clues and his camera placement denoting power in scenes beget a compelling aesthetic composition. Tom Burton’s production design, along with the cinematography, is no nearly as bleak and gloomy as part 1, but it still casts a dark cloud over the film. The color yellow is used as an interesting contrast in Peter Hunt’s hotel room (I am not sure what it means, but it is quite noticeable). Dickson Hinchliffe’s score is very fitting to the detective mystery style of the film. The film being more plot than character driven left lead Paddy Considine with more of a going from point A to B to C to solve the mystery type of role, rather than one with a lot of emotional heavy lifting, but there were a few scenes in which he did have to portray the failures in his character’s life and he did so well. Maxine Peake’s character is a bit of a mystery, in that the viewer is never sure what she is fully up to or about; though certainly has some internal trauma. She, like Considine, is good in her role, as is the cast overall. However, it is Sean Harris that has the most interesting character and gives the scene stealing performance of the film. He is fabulous, hiding true evil behind a mask of blunt incapacity that almost plays as innocence (though we already know him from the first), cracking at times revealing glimpses of complete hate. Like the first part, Red Riding: 1980 is a very well made and aesthetically engaging film.

Red Riding: 1980 is a simple detective mystery on the surface, with a little Hitchcock MacGuffin thrown in for good measure, but underneath it is another fine study of human corruption continuing the series. 7/10

Available on Blu-ray and DVD on Amazon.com or watch it now streaming on Netflix.com

Thursday, September 16, 2010

Red Riding: In the Year of Our Lord 1974 (2010) – Review

Red Riding: In the Year of Our Lord 1974 (from now on being referred to as Red Riding: 1974) is the first in the Red Riding Trilogy (based on the book by David Peace). The film is dark, cryptic and unflinching – yet beautifully shot, directed and acted. Director Julian Jarrold’s narrative does not seem reliable throughout, as it jumps around in time, between dream, perception and reality. The viewer is not quite sure what they are seeing. But by the end of the film, everything comes together and the journey feels satisfying – albeit emotionally draining. The film is structured as a mystery following an investigator, Eddie Dunford, as he looks into the disappearance of a young girl, but this is only the surface of the narrative. It delves deep into the emotions of persecution, love, anguish – human tragedy in different forms is always at the core. Devastatingly bleak and violent imagery is juxtaposed to rays of light breaking through gloomy clouds. This is a motif that Jarrold uses many times in the film, and it is quite striking and beautiful. As if, this one reporter, trying to uncover the truth, even at the highest cost, delivers humanity from the corruption that plagues it – the devil triumphs when good men do nowt. The transformation of Eddie is profound – is it love and loss that compels him, or is it finding the truth – probably a bit of both. He is a character defined by love and loss, but thought of by his friend as a good person. Naivety, ambition and inexperience may have led him to his journey, but these petty characteristics fade as deeper emotions take hold.  As a viewer, Eddie does not make decisions that we understand or would replicate – and what does that say about us. When façade is stripped away, all we have left is base instinct dictated not by social laws but by internal (call it spiritual or core) moral personal laws that bind us to do what we must, and for Eddie, above all else, the truth will out – at any cost. And this, like the depravity juxtaposed to beams of light erupting from dark clouds, is cut against seemingly absolute corruption. While Eddie does what he believes to be his highest moral calling, when all other avenues are closed, society and those set in place to govern and protect us reject truth utterly. Jarrold’s film looks at evil in society as almost the crushing and overwhelming norm; something that cannot be overcome and thus excepted for what it is, and while serial murderers may seem out of the norm to us, does police and government corruption?  Why is it that those that strive to be good and fight the evil that surrounds them find that they are not championed by society, rather they are wilted and restrained. The film starts and ends in seemingly the same place, society unaffected, unmoved – but good striking out does not go unnoticed on a more personal and specific level. Slowly others take notice. And as this is only the first film in the trilogy – good has taken a foothold, evil not as steady as it was – and much like the light punching through, this story of struggle shows that while we cannot eradicate evil in one fell swoop, evil can be defeated slowly step by step. And once in motion, truth will come to light. Red Riding: 1974 is visually uncompromising, both in its beauty and in its gritty and stark look at the corruption of humanity.

On to the technical achievements: Julian Jarrold has made his best directorial effort with this film – his use of the camera is profound, focusing the attention of the viewer on very specific elements, both visually and thematically. He pulls focus on the foreground and background, fixates on emotional visual clues rather than just straightforward convergence on the characters’ faces. He wants to tell the narrative in a precise manner, only giving visuals that will forward the journey that he wants the viewer to take, both from a story and emotional standpoint. Chief in his success is the astounding work of cinematographer Rob Hardy, whose other work is not well known or seen, especially for those outside the UK (I hope that this film gets him lots of work on good projects in the future, because he is clearly a rare and gifted talent). Their collaboration is along the same vein as French director Jacques Audiard and his cinematographer Stephane Fontaine stylistically. Production designer Cristina Casali and composer Adrian Johnston both do very good work on the film, capturing the world and atmosphere of the film. Red Riding: 1974 also serves as a breakout/take notice film for actor Andrew Garfield, who is brilliant. His work carries a seemingly convoluted narrative, anchoring it and giving it a moral core. The film is designed to center around his performance, and he does not let it down. Sean Bean and Rebecca Hall are also standouts among a cast that is good across the board. This is a film that tackles a difficult subject and comes at it through a complicated narrative structure, yet the quality of all those involved see it succeed in being a very aesthetically interesting and emotional provocative film.

Red Riding: 1974 sets the bar high for the rest of the series, as it is a visually remarkable and intensely engaging work. 8/10

The series is available on Blu-ray and DVD at Amazon.com and currently streaming on Netflix.